{
  "schema_version": "claim_identification_view.v2",
  "source_files_used": [
    "Fact_Ledger_base.json",
    "BO.json",
    "evidence_indexed.json",
    "fact_actio_support.json",
    "evidence_actio_support.json",
    "actio_case_signals.json"
  ],
  "case_context": {
    "is_actio_pauliana_suspected": true,
    "suspicion_level": "high",
    "suspicion_reasons": [
      "채무자(김수경)가 부도 후 복수의 부동산을 친족에게 처분함",
      "원고(우방캐피탈, 우방신용)의 피보전채권이 처분행위 이전부터 존재함",
      "채무자의 자산처분 후 현재 재산이 전무한 상태",
      "수익자들이 채무자의 친족으로서 악의 추정 가능",
      "처분 당시 채무자의 채무초과 상태 추정"
    ],
    "related_bo_ids": [
      "bh10",
      "bh12",
      "bh17",
      "bh20"
    ],
    "related_evidence_indexes": [
      "E-001",
      "E-007",
      "E-014",
      "E-017"
    ]
  },
  "items": [
    {
      "fact_id": "F-001",
      "bo_id": "bh1",
      "reason_bo_id": null,
      "prior_bo_id": null,
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": null,
      "event_date": "2013-10-08",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "소비대차",
      "action_text": "소비대차: 우방캐피탈이 개성금속에게 10억 원을 대출하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방캐피탈이 개성금속에게 10억 원을 대출하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "소비대차: 우방캐피탈이 개성금속에게 10억 원을 대출하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "소비대차",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "금전 대출로서 소비대차 계약에 해당",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방캐피탈",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "개성금속",
        "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방캐피탈",
          "개성금속",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방캐피탈",
        "개성금속"
      ],
      "object_spec": "10억 원 대출",
      "fact_object_spec": "10억 원 대출",
      "bo_object": "10억 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "1,000,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-002",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방캐피탈 대출채권",
      "claim_event_type": "대여",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": "2013-10-08",
      "claim_maturity_date": "2015-11-30",
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "1,000,000,000원",
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": "1,260,000,000원",
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": "월 0.5%",
      "claim_default_rate": "월 1%",
      "claim_component_breakdown": [
        "원금 1,000,000,000원",
        "연체이자 260,000,000원"
      ],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "연체",
        "발생"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "소비대차",
        "금전대여",
        "대출"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-012 (대출거래약정서 (기업용))",
        "E-008 (대출명세표)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-012",
        "E-008"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "대출거래약정서 (기업용)",
        "대출명세표"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 2,
        "evidence_index_count": 2,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-012",
          "E-008"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": true,
        "corroboration_summary": "보강",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-012",
          "E-008"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_guarantor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_maturity_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_total_amount_at_act": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_interest_rate": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_default_rate": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_component_breakdown": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {
          "claim_status_tags": {
            "fact_ledger": [
              "연체"
            ],
            "linked_evidence_extra": [
              "발생"
            ]
          }
        },
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": true,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-002",
      "bo_id": "bh2",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh1",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh1",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-001",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-001",
      "event_date": "2013-10-08",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "연대보증",
      "action_text": "연대보증: 김수경이 개성금속의 우방캐피탈에 대한 채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 개성금속의 우방캐피탈에 대한 채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "연대보증: 김수경이 개성금속의 우방캐피탈에 대한 채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "보증",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "연대보증계약 체결",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "개성금속",
          "우방캐피탈"
        ],
        "other_parties": [
          "개성금속"
        ]
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "개성금속",
        "우방캐피탈"
      ],
      "object_spec": "연대보증",
      "fact_object_spec": "연대보증",
      "bo_object": "개성금속의 10억 원 대출채무",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "1,000,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "claim_principal_amount_at_act",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-002",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방캐피탈 대출채권",
      "claim_event_type": "대여",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": "2013-10-08",
      "claim_maturity_date": "2015-11-30",
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "1,000,000,000원",
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": "월 0.5%",
      "claim_default_rate": "월 1%",
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "발생"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "연대보증",
        "보증채무"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-012 (대출거래약정서 (기업용))"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-012"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "대출거래약정서 (기업용)"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-012"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-012"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_guarantor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_maturity_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_interest_rate": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_default_rate": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": true,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-003",
      "bo_id": "bh3",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh1",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh2",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-001",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-002",
      "event_date": "2013-10-07",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "근저당권 설정 계약",
      "action_text": "근저당권 설정 계약: 김수경이 우방캐피탈에게 공장 건물과 공장 부지를 담보로 제공하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 우방캐피탈에게 공장 건물과 공장 부지를 담보로 제공하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "근저당권 설정 계약: 김수경이 우방캐피탈에게 공장 건물과 공장 부지를 담보로 제공하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "(근)저당권 설정 계약",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "근저당권설정계약서에 의한 담보설정",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": "김수경",
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "우방캐피탈",
          "개성금속"
        ],
        "other_parties": [
          "개성금속"
        ]
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "우방캐피탈",
        "개성금속"
      ],
      "object_spec": "공장용지 담보",
      "fact_object_spec": "공장용지 담보",
      "bo_object": "용인시 구성면 언남리 115-1 공장용지",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "1,500,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": "제1부동산",
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-002",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": "담보제공",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": "김수경",
      "claim_arising_date": "2013-10-07",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": "1,500,000,000원",
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "근저당권설정",
        "담보제공"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-009 (근저당권설정계약서)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-009"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "근저당권설정계약서"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-009"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-009"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "asset_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_security_provider": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_arising_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_secured_cap_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-004",
      "bo_id": "bh4",
      "reason_bo_id": null,
      "prior_bo_id": "bh3",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-003",
      "event_date": "2014-12-01",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "신용보증",
      "action_text": "신용보증: 우방신용이 개성금속의 신한은행 대출에 대해 신용보증서를 발급하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방신용이 개성금속의 대출에 대해 신용보증서를 발급하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "신용보증: 우방신용이 개성금속의 신한은행 대출에 대해 신용보증서를 발급하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "보증",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "신용보증약정에 따른 보증서 발급",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방신용보증보험",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "개성금속",
        "claim_creditor": "우방신용보증보험",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방신용보증보험",
          "개성금속",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방신용보증보험",
        "개성금속"
      ],
      "object_spec": "2억 원 신용보증",
      "fact_object_spec": "2억 원 신용보증",
      "bo_object": "2억 원 신용보증",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "200,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-004",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방신용 신용보증채권",
      "claim_event_type": "신용보증",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "법정채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방신용보증보험",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": "2014-12-01",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": "200,000,000원",
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "발생"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "신용보증",
        "보증서발급"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-005 (신용보증약정서(개별거래용))"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-005"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "신용보증약정서(개별거래용)"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-005"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-005"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_guarantor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-005",
      "bo_id": "bh5",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh4",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh4",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-004",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-004",
      "event_date": "2014-12-01",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "연대보증",
      "action_text": "연대보증: 김수경이 개성금속의 우방신용에 대한 구상채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 개성금속의 우방신용에 대한 구상채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "연대보증: 김수경이 개성금속의 우방신용에 대한 구상채무를 연대보증하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "보증",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "구상채무에 대한 연대보증",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "우방신용보증보험",
        "claim_creditor": "우방신용보증보험",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "개성금속",
          "우방신용보증보험"
        ],
        "other_parties": [
          "개성금속"
        ]
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "개성금속",
        "우방신용보증보험"
      ],
      "object_spec": "구상채무 보증",
      "fact_object_spec": "구상채무 보증",
      "bo_object": "개성금속의 구상채무",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "200,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "claim_guarantee_limit_amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-004",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방신용 신용보증채권",
      "claim_event_type": "신용보증",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "법정채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방신용보증보험",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": "김수경",
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": "2014-12-01",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": "200,000,000원",
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "발생"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "연대보증",
        "구상채무보증"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-005 (신용보증약정서(개별거래용))"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-005"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "신용보증약정서(개별거래용)"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-005"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-005"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_guarantor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_arising_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-006",
      "bo_id": "bh6",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh1",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh5",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-001",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-005",
      "event_date": "2015-11-30",
      "event_class": "위법행위",
      "action_label": "채무불이행",
      "action_text": "채무불이행: 개성금속이 대출변제기 도래에도 불구하고 변제하지 못하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "개성금속이 대출변제기 도래에도 불구하고 변제하지 못하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "채무불이행: 개성금속이 대출변제기 도래에도 불구하고 변제하지 못하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": null,
        "gubun_multi": [],
        "basis_note": null,
        "needs_review": null
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "개성금속",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "개성금속",
          "우방캐피탈"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "개성금속",
        "우방캐피탈"
      ],
      "object_spec": "10억 원 대출금",
      "fact_object_spec": "10억 원 대출금",
      "bo_object": "10억 원 대출금",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "1,000,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-002",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방캐피탈 대출채권",
      "claim_event_type": "대여",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": "2013-10-08",
      "claim_maturity_date": "2015-11-30",
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "1,000,000,000원",
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": "1,260,000,000원",
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": "월 0.5%",
      "claim_default_rate": "월 1%",
      "claim_component_breakdown": [
        "원금 1,000,000,000원",
        "연체이자 260,000,000원"
      ],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "연체"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "채무불이행",
        "기한도래",
        "연체"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-008 (대출명세표)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-008"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "대출명세표"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-008"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-008"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_maturity_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_principal_amount_at_act": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_total_amount_at_act": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_interest_rate": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_default_rate": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_component_breakdown": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": true,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-007",
      "bo_id": "bh7",
      "reason_bo_id": "자금사정 악화",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh6",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-006",
      "event_date": "2015-12-01",
      "event_class": "사실행위",
      "action_label": "부도",
      "action_text": "부도: 개성금속이 부도를 내었다.",
      "fact_action_text": "개성금속이 부도를 내었다.",
      "bo_action_text": "부도: 개성금속이 부도를 내었다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": null,
        "gubun_multi": [],
        "basis_note": null,
        "needs_review": null
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "개성금속",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": null,
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "개성금속"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "개성금속"
      ],
      "object_spec": null,
      "fact_object_spec": null,
      "bo_object": null,
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": null,
      "amount_source_field": null,
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "부도",
        "도산"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [],
      "evidence_indexes": [],
      "evidence_titles": [],
      "credibility": "low",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 0,
        "evidence_index_count": 0,
        "evidence_indexes": [],
        "has_direct_evidence": null,
        "has_indirect_evidence": null,
        "has_contrary_evidence": null,
        "has_corroboration": null,
        "corroboration_summary": null,
        "authentication_status_summary": null,
        "authentication_statuses": [],
        "content_relevance_summary": null
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {},
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": false
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": false,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-008",
      "bo_id": "bh8",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh7",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh7",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-007",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-007",
      "event_date": "2015-12-01",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "대위변제",
      "action_text": "대위변제: 우방신용이 신한은행에 개성금속의 대출원리금 2억 2천만 원을 대위변제하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방신용이 신한은행에 개성금속의 대출원리금을 대위변제하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "대위변제: 우방신용이 신한은행에 개성금속의 대출원리금 2억 2천만 원을 대위변제하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "제3자 대위변제로서 구상권 발생",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방신용보증보험",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "신한은행",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방신용보증보험",
          "신한은행",
          "개성금속"
        ],
        "other_parties": [
          "개성금속"
        ]
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방신용보증보험",
        "신한은행",
        "개성금속"
      ],
      "object_spec": "2억 2천만 원",
      "fact_object_spec": "2억 2천만 원",
      "bo_object": "2억 2천만 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "220,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": "대위변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "대위변제",
        "구상권발생"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [],
      "evidence_indexes": [],
      "evidence_titles": [],
      "credibility": "low",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 0,
        "evidence_index_count": 0,
        "evidence_indexes": [],
        "has_direct_evidence": null,
        "has_indirect_evidence": null,
        "has_contrary_evidence": null,
        "has_corroboration": null,
        "corroboration_summary": null,
        "authentication_status_summary": null,
        "authentication_statuses": [],
        "content_relevance_summary": null
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {},
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": false
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-009",
      "bo_id": "bh9",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh8",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh8",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-008",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-008",
      "event_date": "2015-12-22",
      "event_class": "소송행위",
      "action_label": "가압류",
      "action_text": "가압류: 우방신용이 공장용지(용인시 구성면 언남리 115-1)를 가압류하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방신용이 공장용지를 가압류하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "가압류: 우방신용이 공장용지(용인시 구성면 언남리 115-1)를 가압류하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": null,
        "gubun_multi": [],
        "basis_note": null,
        "needs_review": null
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방신용보증보험",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "김수경",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방신용보증보험",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방신용보증보험",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "공장용지 가압류",
      "fact_object_spec": "공장용지 가압류",
      "bo_object": "용인시 구성면 언남리 115-1 공장용지",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": null,
      "amount_source_field": null,
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "가압류",
        "보전처분"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [],
      "evidence_indexes": [],
      "evidence_titles": [],
      "credibility": "low",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 0,
        "evidence_index_count": 0,
        "evidence_indexes": [],
        "has_direct_evidence": null,
        "has_indirect_evidence": null,
        "has_contrary_evidence": null,
        "has_corroboration": null,
        "corroboration_summary": null,
        "authentication_status_summary": null,
        "authentication_statuses": [],
        "content_relevance_summary": null
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {},
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": false
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": false,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-010",
      "bo_id": "bh10",
      "reason_bo_id": "4억 원 차용금 변제",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh9",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-009",
      "event_date": "2016-01-31",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "대물변제",
      "action_text": "대물변제: 김수경이 유재석에게 장미아파트를 4억 원 차용금에 대한 대물변제로 양도하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 유재석에게 장미아파트를 대물변제로 양도하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "대물변제: 김수경이 유재석에게 장미아파트를 4억 원 차용금에 대한 대물변제로 양도하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "대물변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "물권행위",
          "출연행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "차용금채무에 갈음한 부동산 양도",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "유재석",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "유재석"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "유재석"
      ],
      "object_spec": "장미아파트",
      "fact_object_spec": "장미아파트",
      "bo_object": "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "400,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "대물변제",
        "transaction_date": "2016-01-31",
        "registration_date": "2016-01-31",
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": "제1912호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "400,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "대물변제",
        "소유권이전",
        "처분행위"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-014 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-014"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-014"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-014"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "fact_ledger",
          "transaction_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registration_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_receipt_no": "fact_ledger",
          "sale_price": "fact_ledger"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2016-01-31",
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-014"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-011",
      "bo_id": "bh11",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh6",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh10",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-006",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-010",
      "event_date": "2016-04-01",
      "event_class": "소송행위",
      "action_label": "임의경매신청",
      "action_text": "임의경매신청: 우방캐피탈이 공장용지에 관하여 임의경매를 신청하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방캐피탈이 공장용지에 관하여 임의경매를 신청하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "임의경매신청: 우방캐피탈이 공장용지에 관하여 임의경매를 신청하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": null,
        "gubun_multi": [],
        "basis_note": null,
        "needs_review": null
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방캐피탈",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": "김수경",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방캐피탈",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방캐피탈",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "공장용지",
      "fact_object_spec": "공장용지",
      "bo_object": "용인시 구성면 언남리 115-1 공장용지",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "1,100,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": "제1부동산",
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": "1,100,000,000원",
        "market_value_at_close": "1,100,000,000원",
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "임의경매",
        "담보권실행"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-004 (감정평가서)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-004"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "감정평가서"
      ],
      "credibility": "medium",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-004"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": false,
        "has_indirect_evidence": true,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "간접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-004"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "asset_id": "fact_ledger",
          "market_value_at_act": "fact_ledger",
          "market_value_at_close": "fact_ledger"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-012",
      "bo_id": "bh12",
      "reason_bo_id": "경매 진행 중 매각 방지 목적",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh11",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-011",
      "event_date": "2017-08-31",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "매매",
      "action_text": "매매: 김수경이 박수용에게 주공아파트를 4억 3천만 원에 매도하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 박수용에게 주공아파트를 매도하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "매매: 김수경이 박수용에게 주공아파트를 4억 3천만 원에 매도하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "매매",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위",
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "부동산 매매계약 및 소유권이전",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "박수용",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "박수용"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "박수용"
      ],
      "object_spec": "주공아파트",
      "fact_object_spec": "주공아파트",
      "bo_object": "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "430,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "매매",
        "transaction_date": "2017-08-31",
        "registration_date": "2017-09-17",
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": "제80555호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "2017-08-31",
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "430,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": [
          "국민은행 채무 130,000,000원",
          "하나은행 채무 50,000,000원",
          "임대보증금 채무 100,000,000원",
          "신용보증기금 채무 20,000,000원",
          "최상수 채무 100,000,000원"
        ]
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "매매",
        "소유권이전",
        "처분행위"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-007 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물)",
        "E-017 (不動産賣買契約書)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-007",
        "E-017"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물",
        "不動産賣買契約書"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 2,
        "evidence_index_count": 2,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-007",
          "E-017"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": true,
        "corroboration_summary": "보강",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-007",
          "E-017"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "fact_ledger",
          "transaction_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registration_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_receipt_no": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "fact_ledger",
          "sale_price": "fact_ledger",
          "consideration_breakdown": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물",
          "수익자이익"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2017-08-31",
        "beneficiary_gain_support": {
          "beneficiary_name": "박수용",
          "nominal_transfer_value": "430000000원",
          "estimation_basis": "매매계약상 승계 채무 합계",
          "proof_doc": "E-017",
          "confidence": "high"
        },
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-007",
          "E-017"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-013",
      "bo_id": "bh13",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh12",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh12",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-012",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-012",
      "event_date": "2017-09-15",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "변제",
      "action_text": "변제: 박수용이 하나은행에 근저당권 피담보채무 5천만 원을 변제하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "박수용이 하나은행에 근저당권 피담보채무를 변제하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "변제: 박수용이 하나은행에 근저당권 피담보채무 5천만 원을 변제하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "근저당권 피담보채무 변제",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "박수용",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "하나은행",
        "claim_creditor": "하나은행",
        "claim_debtor": "김수경",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "박수용",
          "하나은행",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": [
          "김수경"
        ]
      },
      "actors": [
        "박수용",
        "하나은행",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "하나은행 채무",
      "fact_object_spec": "하나은행 채무",
      "bo_object": "5천만 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "50,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-009",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "하나은행 근저당권 피담보채권",
      "claim_event_type": "변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "하나은행",
      "claim_debtor": "김수경",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2017-09-15",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "50,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "소멸",
        "완제"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "변제",
        "담보권소멸"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-018 (변제확인서)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-018"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "변제확인서"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-018"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-018"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_performance_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {
          "claim_status_tags": {
            "fact_ledger": [
              "소멸"
            ],
            "linked_evidence_extra": [
              "완제"
            ]
          }
        },
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-018"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high"
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-014",
      "bo_id": "bh14",
      "reason_bo_id": null,
      "prior_bo_id": "bh13",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-013",
      "event_date": "2017-09-16",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "소비대차",
      "action_text": "소비대차: 김수철이 김수경에게 3억 원을 대여하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수철이 김수경에게 3억 원을 대여하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "소비대차: 김수철이 김수경에게 3억 원을 대여하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "소비대차",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "금전 대여",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수철",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "김수경",
        "claim_creditor": "우리은행",
        "claim_debtor": "김수경",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수철",
          "김수경",
          "우리은행"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수철",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "3억 원 대여",
      "fact_object_spec": "3억 원 대여",
      "bo_object": "3억 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "300,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-008",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우리은행 근저당권 피담보채권",
      "claim_event_type": "변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우리은행",
      "claim_debtor": "김수경",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2017-09-16",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "300,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "완제",
        "소멸"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "소비대차",
        "금전대여"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-016 (확인서)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-016"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "확인서"
      ],
      "credibility": "medium",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": false,
        "has_indirect_evidence": true,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "간접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_performance_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high"
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-015",
      "bo_id": "bh15",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh14",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh14",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-014",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-014",
      "event_date": "2017-09-16",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "변제",
      "action_text": "변제: 김수경이 우리은행에 근저당권 피담보채무 3억 원을 변제하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 우리은행에 근저당권 피담보채무를 변제하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "변제: 김수경이 우리은행에 근저당권 피담보채무 3억 원을 변제하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "근저당권 피담보채무 변제로 담보권 소멸",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "우리은행",
        "claim_creditor": "우리은행",
        "claim_debtor": "김수경",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "우리은행"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "우리은행"
      ],
      "object_spec": "우리은행 채무",
      "fact_object_spec": "우리은행 채무",
      "bo_object": "3억 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "300,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-008",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우리은행 근저당권 피담보채권",
      "claim_event_type": "변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우리은행",
      "claim_debtor": "김수경",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2017-09-16",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "300,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "소멸",
        "완제"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "변제",
        "담보권말소"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-016 (확인서)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-016"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "확인서"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_performance_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {
          "claim_status_tags": {
            "fact_ledger": [
              "소멸"
            ],
            "linked_evidence_extra": [
              "완제"
            ]
          }
        },
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-016"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high"
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-016",
      "bo_id": "bh16",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh12",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh15",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-012",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-015",
      "event_date": "2017-09-17",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "소유권이전등기",
      "action_text": "소유권이전등기: 박수용이 주공아파트에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "fact_action_text": "박수용이 주공아파트에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "bo_action_text": "소유권이전등기: 박수용이 주공아파트에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "소유권이전의 합의",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "등기에 의한 물권변동",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "박수용",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "김수경",
        "claim_creditor": null,
        "claim_debtor": null,
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "박수용",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "박수용",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "주공아파트 이전등기",
      "fact_object_spec": "주공아파트 이전등기",
      "bo_object": "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "430,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "sale_price",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "매매",
        "transaction_date": "2017-08-31",
        "registration_date": "2017-09-17",
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": "제80555호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "2017-08-31",
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "430,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": null,
      "claim_label_for_schedule": null,
      "claim_event_type": null,
      "claim_nature_tags": [],
      "claim_creditor": null,
      "claim_debtor": null,
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "소유권이전등기",
        "물권변동"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-007 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-007"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 집합건물"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-007"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-007"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "linked_evidence",
          "transaction_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registration_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_receipt_no": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "linked_evidence",
          "sale_price": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": false,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": false,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2017-08-31",
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-007"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-017",
      "bo_id": "bh17",
      "reason_bo_id": "대여금채권 3억 원을 매매대금으로 갈음",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh16",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-016",
      "event_date": "2017-09-24",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "매매",
      "action_text": "매매: 김수경이 김수철에게 김포시 운양동 토지를 3억 원에 매도하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수경이 김수철에게 김포시 운양동 토지를 매도하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "매매: 김수경이 김수철에게 김포시 운양동 토지를 3억 원에 매도하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "매매",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "채권행위",
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "부동산 매매계약",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수경",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "김수철",
        "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
        "claim_debtor": "김수철",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
        "all_parties": [
          "김수경",
          "김수철",
          "최종찬"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수경",
        "김수철"
      ],
      "object_spec": "김포시 운양동 토지",
      "fact_object_spec": "김포시 운양동 토지",
      "bo_object": "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "300,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "매매",
        "transaction_date": "2017-09-24",
        "registration_date": "2017-09-25",
        "registry_office": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
        "registry_receipt_no": "제29757호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "2017-09-24",
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "300,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-001",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "김수철 근저당권 채권",
      "claim_event_type": "담보제공",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
      "claim_debtor": "김수철",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
      "claim_arising_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_instrument_identifier": "제33456호",
      "claim_instrument_issuer": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": "300,000,000원",
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "매매",
        "소유권이전",
        "처분행위"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-001 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-001"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "fact_ledger",
          "transaction_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registration_date": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_office": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_receipt_no": "fact_ledger",
          "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "fact_ledger",
          "sale_price": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_security_provider": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_identifier": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_issuer": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_secured_cap_amount": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물",
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2017-09-24",
        "encumbrances_at_fraudulent_act": [
          {
            "kind": "근저당",
            "holder": "최종찬",
            "rank": 1,
            "registered_max_amount": "300000000원",
            "supported_date": "2017-09-27",
            "proof_doc": "E-001",
            "proof_strength": "direct"
          }
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-018",
      "bo_id": "bh18",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh12",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh17",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-012",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-017",
      "event_date": "2017-09-25",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "변제",
      "action_text": "변제: 박수용이 최상수에게 근저당권 피담보채무 1억 원을 변제하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "박수용이 최상수에 근저당권 피담보채무를 변제하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "변제: 박수용이 최상수에게 근저당권 피담보채무 1억 원을 변제하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "근저당권 피담보채무 변제",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "박수용",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "최상수",
        "claim_creditor": "최상수",
        "claim_debtor": "김수경",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "박수용",
          "최상수",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "박수용",
        "최상수"
      ],
      "object_spec": "최상수 채무",
      "fact_object_spec": "최상수 채무",
      "bo_object": "1억 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "100,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-003",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "최상수 근저당권 피담보채권",
      "claim_event_type": "변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "최상수",
      "claim_debtor": "김수경",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2017-09-25",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "100,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "소멸",
        "완제"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "변제",
        "담보권말소"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-003 (영수증)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-003"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "영수증"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-003"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-003"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_performance_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {
          "claim_status_tags": {
            "fact_ledger": [
              "소멸"
            ],
            "linked_evidence_extra": [
              "완제"
            ]
          }
        },
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-019",
      "bo_id": "bh19",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh17",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh18",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-017",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-018",
      "event_date": "2017-09-25",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "소유권이전등기",
      "action_text": "소유권이전등기: 김수철이 김포시 운양동 토지에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수철이 김포시 운양동 토지에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "bo_action_text": "소유권이전등기: 김수철이 김포시 운양동 토지에 대한 소유권이전등기를 경료받았다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "소유권이전의 합의",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "등기에 의한 물권변동",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수철",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "김수경",
        "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
        "claim_debtor": "김수철",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
        "all_parties": [
          "김수철",
          "김수경",
          "최종찬"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수철",
        "김수경"
      ],
      "object_spec": "토지 이전등기",
      "fact_object_spec": "토지 이전등기",
      "bo_object": "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "300,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "claim_secured_cap_amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "매매",
        "transaction_date": "2017-09-24",
        "registration_date": "2017-09-25",
        "registry_office": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
        "registry_receipt_no": "제29757호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "2017-09-24",
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "300,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-001",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "김수철 근저당권 채권",
      "claim_event_type": "담보제공",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
      "claim_debtor": "김수철",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
      "claim_arising_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_instrument_identifier": "제33456호",
      "claim_instrument_issuer": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": "300,000,000원",
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "소유권이전등기",
        "물권변동"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-001 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-001"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "linked_evidence",
          "transaction_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registration_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_office": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_receipt_no": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "linked_evidence",
          "sale_price": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_id": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_creditor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_debtor": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_security_provider": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_arising_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_date": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_identifier": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_instrument_issuer": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_secured_cap_amount": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_nature_tags": "linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": false,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물",
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2017-09-24",
        "encumbrances_at_fraudulent_act": [
          {
            "kind": "근저당",
            "holder": "최종찬",
            "rank": 1,
            "registered_max_amount": "300000000원",
            "supported_date": "2017-09-27",
            "proof_doc": "E-001",
            "proof_strength": "direct"
          }
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-020",
      "bo_id": "bh20",
      "reason_bo_id": null,
      "prior_bo_id": "bh19",
      "reason_fact_id": null,
      "prior_fact_id": "F-019",
      "event_date": "2017-09-26",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "근저당권 설정 계약",
      "action_text": "근저당권 설정 계약: 김수철이 최종찬에게 김포시 운양동 토지에 채권최고액 3억 원의 근저당권을 설정하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "김수철이 최종찬에게 토지에 근저당권을 설정하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "근저당권 설정 계약: 김수철이 최종찬에게 김포시 운양동 토지에 채권최고액 3억 원의 근저당권을 설정하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "(근)저당권 설정 계약",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "계약행위",
          "물권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "근저당권설정계약",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "김수철",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "최종찬",
        "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
        "claim_debtor": "김수철",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
        "all_parties": [
          "김수철",
          "최종찬"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "김수철",
        "최종찬"
      ],
      "object_spec": "근저당권설정",
      "fact_object_spec": "근저당권설정",
      "bo_object": "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "300,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": "매매",
        "transaction_date": "2017-09-24",
        "registration_date": "2017-09-25",
        "registry_office": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
        "registry_receipt_no": "제29757호",
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "2017-09-24",
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": "300,000,000원",
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-001",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "김수철 근저당권 채권",
      "claim_event_type": "담보제공",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "최종찬",
      "claim_debtor": "김수철",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": "김수철",
      "claim_arising_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_date": "2017-09-26",
      "claim_instrument_identifier": "제33456호",
      "claim_instrument_issuer": "인천지방법원 부천지원 김포등기소",
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": null,
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": "300,000,000원",
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "근저당권설정",
        "담보제공"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-001 (등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-001"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "등기사항전부증명서(말소사항 포함) - 토지"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "transaction_type": "linked_evidence",
          "transaction_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registration_date": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_office": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_receipt_no": "linked_evidence",
          "registry_recorded_transfer_date": "linked_evidence",
          "sale_price": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_security_provider": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_arising_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_instrument_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_instrument_identifier": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_instrument_issuer": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_secured_cap_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": true,
        "has_actio_support": true
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": {
        "is_actio_pauliana_relevant_candidate": true,
        "support_role_tags": [
          "사해행위목적물",
          "선순위담보"
        ],
        "fraudulent_act_date": "2017-09-24",
        "encumbrances_at_fraudulent_act": [
          {
            "kind": "근저당",
            "holder": "최종찬",
            "rank": 1,
            "registered_max_amount": "300000000원",
            "supported_date": "2017-09-27",
            "proof_doc": "E-001",
            "proof_strength": "direct"
          }
        ],
        "support_evidence_indexes": [
          "E-001"
        ],
        "confidence_score_summary": "high",
        "case_signal_match": {
          "suspicion_level": "high",
          "target_property_candidates": [
            "서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 38-1 장미아파트 2동 206호",
            "서울특별시 강남구 개포동 715 주공아파트 2차 203동 202호",
            "경기도 김포시 운양동 347 잡종지 500㎡"
          ],
          "fraudulent_act_date_candidates": [
            "2016-01-31",
            "2017-08-31",
            "2017-09-24"
          ],
          "preserved_claim_candidates": [
            {
              "bo_id": "bh2",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방캐피탈",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh5",
              "claim_type_candidate": "guarantee",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            },
            {
              "bo_id": "bh8",
              "claim_type_candidate": "reimbursement",
              "creditor_candidate": "우방신용보증보험",
              "debtor_candidate": "김수경"
            }
          ],
          "beneficiary_candidates": [
            "유재석",
            "박수용",
            "김수철",
            "최종찬"
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-021",
      "bo_id": "bh21",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh12",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh20",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-012",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-020",
      "event_date": "2017-11-11",
      "event_class": "법률행위",
      "action_label": "변제",
      "action_text": "변제: 박수용이 신용보증기금에 가압류 피보전채권 2천만 원을 변제하였다.",
      "fact_action_text": "박수용이 신용보증기금에 가압류 피보전채권을 변제하였다.",
      "bo_action_text": "변제: 박수용이 신용보증기금에 가압류 피보전채권 2천만 원을 변제하였다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": "변제",
        "gubun_multi": [
          "채권행위"
        ],
        "basis_note": "가압류 피보전채권 변제",
        "needs_review": false
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "박수용",
        "performer_type": "자연인",
        "subject": "신용보증기금",
        "claim_creditor": "신용보증기금",
        "claim_debtor": "김수경",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "박수용",
          "신용보증기금",
          "김수경"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "박수용",
        "신용보증기금"
      ],
      "object_spec": "가압류 채무",
      "fact_object_spec": "가압류 채무",
      "bo_object": "2천만 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "20,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-005",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "신용보증기금 가압류채권",
      "claim_event_type": "변제",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "신용보증기금",
      "claim_debtor": "김수경",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2017-11-11",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "20,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": null,
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "소멸"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "변제",
        "가압류해제"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-006 (영수증)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-006"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "영수증"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-006"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-006"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "linked_evidence",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_performance_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    },
    {
      "fact_id": "F-022",
      "bo_id": "bh22",
      "reason_bo_id": "bh11",
      "prior_bo_id": "bh21",
      "reason_fact_id": "F-011",
      "prior_fact_id": "F-021",
      "event_date": "2018-01-31",
      "event_class": "소송행위",
      "action_label": "배당",
      "action_text": "배당: 우방캐피탈이 공장용지 임의경매에서 9억 6천만 원을 배당받았다.",
      "fact_action_text": "우방캐피탈이 공장용지 임의경매에서 9억 6천만 원을 배당받았다.",
      "bo_action_text": "배당: 우방캐피탈이 공장용지 임의경매에서 9억 6천만 원을 배당받았다.",
      "juristic_act": {
        "label": null,
        "gubun_multi": [],
        "basis_note": null,
        "needs_review": null
      },
      "party_roles": {
        "performer": "우방캐피탈",
        "performer_type": "법인",
        "subject": null,
        "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
        "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
        "claim_guarantor": null,
        "claim_security_provider": null,
        "all_parties": [
          "우방캐피탈",
          "개성금속"
        ],
        "other_parties": []
      },
      "actors": [
        "우방캐피탈"
      ],
      "object_spec": "배당금",
      "fact_object_spec": "배당금",
      "bo_object": "9억 6천만 원",
      "location": null,
      "method": null,
      "outcome": null,
      "amount": "960,000,000원",
      "amount_source_field": "fact.amount",
      "property_transaction": {
        "asset_id": null,
        "property_label_for_schedule": null,
        "transaction_type": null,
        "transaction_date": null,
        "registration_date": null,
        "registry_office": null,
        "registry_receipt_no": null,
        "registry_recorded_transfer_date": null,
        "market_value_at_act": null,
        "market_value_at_close": null,
        "sale_price": null,
        "consideration_breakdown": []
      },
      "claim_id": "CLM-002",
      "claim_label_for_schedule": "우방캐피탈 대출채권",
      "claim_event_type": "배당",
      "claim_nature_tags": [
        "금전채권",
        "이자채권"
      ],
      "claim_creditor": "우방캐피탈",
      "claim_debtor": "개성금속",
      "claim_guarantor": null,
      "claim_security_provider": null,
      "claim_arising_date": null,
      "claim_maturity_date": null,
      "claim_default_or_acceleration_date": null,
      "claim_performance_date": "2018-01-31",
      "claim_instrument_date": null,
      "claim_instrument_identifier": null,
      "claim_instrument_issuer": null,
      "claim_principal_amount_at_act": null,
      "claim_total_amount_at_act": "1,260,000,000원",
      "claim_outstanding_amount_at_close": null,
      "claim_actual_performance_amount": "960,000,000원",
      "claim_guarantee_limit_amount": null,
      "claim_secured_cap_amount": "1,500,000,000원",
      "claim_interest_rate": null,
      "claim_default_rate": null,
      "claim_component_breakdown": [
        "원금 1,000,000,000원",
        "이자 260,000,000원"
      ],
      "claim_status_tags": [
        "배당",
        "일부회수",
        "잔존"
      ],
      "legal_keywords": [
        "배당",
        "채권회수"
      ],
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E-002 (배당표)"
      ],
      "evidence_indexes": [
        "E-002"
      ],
      "evidence_titles": [
        "배당표"
      ],
      "credibility": "high",
      "evidence_strength": {
        "evidence_count": 1,
        "evidence_index_count": 1,
        "evidence_indexes": [
          "E-002"
        ],
        "has_direct_evidence": true,
        "has_indirect_evidence": false,
        "has_contrary_evidence": false,
        "has_corroboration": false,
        "corroboration_summary": "단독",
        "authentication_status_summary": "불명",
        "authentication_statuses": [
          "불명"
        ],
        "content_relevance_summary": "직접"
      },
      "source_trace": {
        "linked_evidence_indexes_with_legal_calc": [
          "E-002"
        ],
        "legal_calculation_field_sources": {
          "claim_id": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_label_for_schedule": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_event_type": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_creditor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_debtor": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_performance_date": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_total_amount_at_act": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_actual_performance_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_secured_cap_amount": "fact_ledger",
          "claim_nature_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_component_breakdown": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence",
          "claim_status_tags": "fact_ledger+linked_evidence"
        },
        "legal_calculation_conflicts": {},
        "used_fact_ledger_legal_calc": true,
        "used_linked_evidence_backfill": true
      },
      "structured_presence_flags": {
        "has_claim_role_direction": true,
        "has_claim_amount_terms": true,
        "has_claim_date_terms": true,
        "has_rate_terms": false,
        "has_property_transfer_terms": false,
        "has_actio_support": false
      },
      "actio_pauliana_support": null
    }
  ]
}