2 lines
19 KiB
JSON
2 lines
19 KiB
JSON
{"template_name":"actio_pauliana_calc_v3","schema_version":"3.0-draft","jurisdiction":"KR","language":"ko-KR","currency":"KRW","purpose":"대한민국 사해행위취소소송의 가액배상 사건에서 소장 단계의 잠정 특정액 산정, 감정 및 증거조사에 따른 중간 보정, 변론종결 직전 최종 금액 확정, 그리고 청구취지·청구원인 문안 입력값 생성을 위한 실무형 계산·검증·문안 엔진","based_on":{"prior_version":"actio_pauliana_calc_v2","drafting_rule_file":"청구취지작성규칙_사해행위취소청구.md","claim_info_family":["C-003_claim_information.json","C-004_claim_information.json","C-005_claim_information.json","C-006_claim_information.json","C-007_claim_information.json","C-008_claim_information.json","C-009_claim_information.json","C-010_claim_information.json"]},"design_principles":["가액배상은 원상회복이 불가능하거나 부적절한 경우에만 선택한다.","소장 단계에서는 변론종결일을 알 수 없으므로 잠정 특정액(provisional filing amount)을 별도 산정한다.","잠정 특정액은 최근 감정가, 공시가격·시가표준액·실거래자료 등 현재 확보 가능한 객관자료, 선순위 담보권 및 공제항목을 반영한 보수적 수치를 우선 사용한다.","변론종결시 시가는 단일 문자열이 아니라 복수 valuation candidate와 각 후보의 날짜·출처·권리상태 스냅샷·기준일과의 거리로 관리한다.","감정신청 또는 시가자료 보강이 이루어지면 청구취지 변경 또는 준비서면 보정 전용 블록을 재생성한다.","최종 청구취지 숫자는 원칙적으로 pre_close_finalization 단계에서만 확정한다.","원고별 피보전채권 총액, 공동담보가액, 수익자 이익 중 최저치를 회복상한(cap)으로 사용한다.","복잡한 이자 계산은 segment_table 기반으로만 수행한다."],"proceeding_stages":{"allowed_values":["filing_provisional","evidence_update","pre_close_finalization","post_close_reference_only"],"current_stage":"filing_provisional","stage_meanings":{"filing_provisional":"소장 제출 또는 초기 준비서면 단계. 변론종결일 미정. 금액은 잠정 특정액으로만 사용 가능.","evidence_update":"감정촉탁, 시가자료, 권리상태 자료가 보강되는 중간 단계. 청구취지 변경 후보를 계산한다.","pre_close_finalization":"예정된 마지막 변론기일 직전 또는 변론종결 직전. 최종 청구취지 확정 단계.","post_close_reference_only":"변론종결 후 기록정리용. 계산 엔진의 재확정에는 사용하지 않는다."}},"runtime_inputs":{"close_of_arguments_date":{"value":null,"required_for":["pre_close_finalization"],"not_required_for":["filing_provisional","evidence_update"],"description":"사실심 변론종결일. 가액배상 최종 확정 시 기준시점. 소장 단계에서는 미정일 수 있다."},"estimated_close_of_arguments_date":{"value":null,"required_for":[],"description":"일정관리 목적의 예측값. 계산의 법적 기준시점으로 사용하지 않는다."},"judgment_finality_date":{"value":null,"required_for":[],"description":"판결 확정일. 판결확정 후 지연손해금 문구용."},"litigation_mode":{"value":"litigation_safe","allowed_values":["strict","best_estimate","litigation_safe"],"description":"선택정책. 소장 단계는 원칙적으로 litigation_safe를 사용한다."},"allow_provisional_filing_amount":{"value":true,"required_for":["filing_provisional","evidence_update"],"description":"변론종결시 시가 미확정 상태에서 잠정 특정액을 산정해 청구취지에 투입할지 여부"},"auto_trigger_appraisal_motion_when_close_value_missing":{"value":true,"required_for":[],"description":"변론종결시 시가 직접자료가 없으면 감정신청 필요 플래그를 자동 생성한다."},"use_existing_interest_template":{"value":true,"required_for":["filing_provisional","evidence_update","pre_close_finalization"],"description":"기존 이자 계산 템플릿 관행을 따른다."}},"source_of_truth":{"primary_input_files":["C-###_claim_information.json","Fact_Ledger.json","evidence_indexed.json","BO.json"],"official_input_layers":{"claim_files":{"paths":["claim_id","claim_statement","plaintiffs[]","defendants[]","source_fact_ids[]","facts[].legal_calculation_object","facts[].evidence_links[].actio_pauliana_support","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support"],"enabled":true},"support_paths":{"paths":["facts[].evidence_links[].actio_pauliana_support.fraudulent_act_date","facts[].evidence_links[].actio_pauliana_support.lease_deposit_deductibility_support","facts[].evidence_links[].actio_pauliana_support.non_deductible_attachment_claims","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support.encumbrances_at_fraudulent_act","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support.encumbrances_at_close_of_arguments","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support.beneficiary_gain_support","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support.plaintiff_claim_snapshots","facts[].fact_actio_support.actio_pauliana_support.legal_meta_flags"],"enabled":true}}},"case_metadata":{"matter_id":null,"claim_group_id":null,"claim_id":null,"working_title":null,"created_at":null,"updated_at":null,"review_status":"draft","overall_confidence":"unknown"},"canonical_case_facts":{"fraudulent_act_date":{"selected_value":null,"candidate_values":[{"date":null,"source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"evidence_refs":[],"inference_note":null,"applies_to_asset_id":null}]},"asset_identity":{"asset_id":null,"property_label_for_schedule":null,"property_type":null,"address":null,"registry_office":null,"registry_receipt_no":null,"registration_date":null,"transaction_type":null,"transaction_date":null},"remedy_gatekeeping":{"default_remedy_mode":"restoration_erasure","selected_remedy_mode":null,"allowed_values":["restoration_erasure","restoration_direct_retransfer","value_compensation_only","restoration_primary_value_compensation_backup"],"is_value_compensation_exception_triggered":null,"exception_reasons":{"transferee_good_faith":false,"encumbrance_existed_at_act_and_released_later":false,"legal_impossibility_of_restoration":false,"factual_impossibility_of_restoration":false,"beneficiary_cannot_restore_property":false,"auction_distribution_makes_natural_restoration_inadequate":false},"reason_fact_ids":[],"manual_review_required":true}},"market_value_policy":{"legal_reference_time":"사실심 변론종결시","practical_handling_when_close_unknown":{"at_filing_stage":"최근 감정가, 공시가격·시가표준액·실거래자료 등 현재 확보 가능한 객관자료와 선순위 담보권 및 공제항목을 반영한 보수적 잠정 특정액을 사용한다.","at_evidence_update_stage":"감정촉탁 결과 또는 보강 증거를 반영하여 잠정 특정액을 재산정하고 청구취지 변경 후보를 생성한다.","at_pre_close_finalization_stage":"예정된 변론종결일과 가까운 평가자료 또는 감정결과를 기준으로 최종 selected_value를 확정한다."},"candidate_selection_rules":["candidate_amount, valuation_date, basis_type, evidence_refs, distance_to_close_days를 반드시 저장한다.","권리상태가 다르면 같은 자산이라도 별도 후보로 저장한다.","감정가가 존재하면 최우선 검토한다.","공시가격·시가표준액·실거래자료는 직접 감정자료 부재 시 보조자료로 사용한다.","임의의 시세상승률·하락률을 자동 적용하지 않는다.","변론종결일이 입력되기 전에는 final_close_value를 확정하지 않는다."],"basis_type_priority":["court_appraisal","private_appraisal_recent","auction_appraisal_recent","recent_actual_transaction_same_asset","official_public_price","tax_assessment_or_market_table","conservative_placeholder"]},"market_value_fields":{"market_value_at_act":{"selected_value":null,"candidate_values":[{"candidate_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"valuation_date":null,"basis_type":null,"evidence_refs":[],"source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","current_use_stage":[],"rights_state_snapshot":null,"note":null,"distance_to_act_days":null}],"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null},"market_value_close_candidates":[{"asset_id":null,"candidate_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"valuation_date":null,"basis_type":null,"evidence_refs":[],"source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","current_use_stage":[],"rights_state_snapshot":null,"note":null,"distance_to_close_days":null,"usable_for_stage":["filing_provisional","evidence_update","pre_close_finalization"]}],"property_value_at_close_of_arguments":{"selected_value":null,"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null,"selection_note":"close_of_arguments_date가 없으면 selected_for_relief는 filing_provisional_selected 또는 interim_selected만 허용한다.","filing_provisional_selected":null,"interim_selected":null,"final_close_selected":null},"provisional_value_compensation_base":{"description":"소장 단계에서 사용하는 잠정 특정액 계산용 기초가치","selected_value":null,"derivation_priority":["최근 감정가","최근 동일 목적물 실거래가","공시가격·시가표준액 등 객관지표","보수적 placeholder"],"deduction_policy":"선순위 담보권, 공제 가능한 임차보증금 등 공제항목을 반영한 보수적 순가치를 사용한다."}},"encumbrance_inputs":{"secured_claims_existing_at_fraudulent_act":[{"identity_key":null,"holder":null,"kind":null,"rank":null,"registered_max_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"actual_secured_debt_at_act":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"deductible_in_value_compensation":null,"deductibility_reason":null,"proof_doc":null,"proof_strength":"unknown","evidence_refs":[]}],"secured_claims_still_existing_at_close":[{"identity_key":null,"holder":null,"kind":null,"rank":null,"actual_outstanding_at_close":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"released_date":null,"released_by_beneficiary":null,"proof_doc":null,"proof_strength":"unknown","evidence_refs":[]}],"lease_deposit_deductibility":{"exists":null,"tenant_name":null,"lease_deposit_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"priority_analysis":{"tenant_has_possession":null,"tenant_has_resident_registration":null,"fixed_date_exists":null,"small_tenant_issue":null,"senior_right_preexists":null},"candidate_values":[{"deductible":null,"reason_text":null,"source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","evidence_refs":[]}],"selected_deductibility":{"deductible":null,"reason_text":null,"source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","evidence_refs":[]},"deductible_amount":{"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null}},"non_deductible_attachment_claims":[{"holder":null,"kind":null,"claim_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"attachment_non_deductible_flag":true,"non_deductible_reason":null,"proof_doc":null,"proof_strength":"unknown","evidence_refs":[]}]},"common_collateral_value":{"asset_level_table":[{"asset_id":null,"property_label_for_schedule":null,"selected_close_value":null,"deductible_senior_burdens":[{"identity_key":null,"amount_krw":null,"reason_text":null}],"deductible_lease_deposit":null,"non_deductible_attachments":[{"identity_key":null,"amount_krw":null}],"asset_net_value_strict":null,"asset_net_value_best_estimate":null,"asset_net_value_litigation_safe":null,"notes":null}],"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null,"formula":"sum(selected_close_value - deductible_senior_burdens - deductible_lease_deposit)","source_refs":[]},"beneficiary_gain":{"components":{"nominal_transfer_value":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"assumed_debt_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"beneficiary_preexisting_claim_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"released_encumbrance_amount":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"other_positive_component":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]},"other_negative_component":{"krw":null,"status":"unknown","source_grade":null,"confidence":"unknown","basis":null,"inference_note":null,"source_refs":[]}},"scenario_table":[{"scenario_id":null,"scenario_label":null,"nominal_transfer_value_krw":null,"assumed_debt_amount_krw":null,"beneficiary_preexisting_claim_amount_krw":null,"released_encumbrance_amount_krw":null,"other_positive_component_krw":null,"other_negative_component_krw":null,"computed_gain":null,"support_level":null,"rationale":null,"evidence_refs":[]}],"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null,"formula":"nominal_transfer_value - assumed_debt_amount - beneficiary_preexisting_claim_amount - other_negative_component + released_encumbrance_amount + other_positive_component","source_refs":[]},"plaintiffs":[{"plaintiff_name":null,"claim_type":null,"plaintiff_claim_snapshot":{"principal_existing_at_fraudulent_act":null,"secured_portion_at_fraudulent_act":null,"unsecured_portion_at_fraudulent_act":null,"contractual_interest_rate":null,"default_interest_rate":null,"interest_start_date":null,"amount_as_of_close_of_arguments":null,"proof_status":"unknown"},"interest_engine":{"complexity_level":"segment_required","segment_table":[{"segment_no":1,"start_date":null,"end_date":null,"days":null,"principal_basis_krw":null,"rate_type":null,"rate_text":null,"rate_numeric_per_annum":null,"start_trigger":null,"end_trigger":null,"accrual_convention":"simple_interest_default","computed_interest":null,"evidence_refs":[],"note":null}],"unresolved_segments":[{"issue":null,"required_input":null,"blocking":false}]},"preserved_claim_principal":{"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null},"preserved_claim_interest_until_close":{"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null},"preserved_claim_total":{"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null},"recovery_cap":{"strict_value":null,"best_estimate":null,"litigation_safe_value":null,"selected_for_relief":null,"formula":"min(common_collateral_value, preserved_claim_total, beneficiary_gain)"},"allocated_recovery_amount":{"filing_provisional":null,"evidence_update":null,"pre_close_finalization":null}}],"drafting_workflow":{"filing_stage_policy":{"use_provisional_amount":true,"default_relief_structure":"원상회복이 가능하면 주위적 원상회복 + 예비적 가액배상","when_value_compensation_is_unavoidable":"전득자 선의, 담보권 사후 소멸, 경매·배당에 따른 현물회복 불능 등 예외사유가 직접 확인되면 잠정 특정액으로 금액청구를 제기하되 감정신청 필요 플래그를 함께 둔다.","cause_summary_phrase":"정확한 가액은 향후 감정결과와 변론종결시 권리상태를 반영하여 보정한다."},"amendment_policy":{"amendment_trigger_categories":["court_appraisal_received","new_market_value_evidence_received","encumbrance_released_or_confirmed","lease_deductibility_changed","close_of_arguments_date_fixed"],"must_regenerate_relief_text_before_close":true,"must_regenerate_cause_text_before_close":true},"relief_text_blocks":{"value_compensation_provisional":{"principal_text":null,"pre_close_interest_text":null,"post_finality_interest_text":null,"combined_relief_text":null},"value_compensation_final":{"principal_text":null,"pre_close_interest_text":null,"post_finality_interest_text":null,"combined_relief_text":null},"restoration_primary_value_backup":{"primary_relief_text":null,"backup_relief_text":null}}},"validation":{"required_runtime_inputs_by_stage":{"filing_provisional":[],"evidence_update":[],"pre_close_finalization":["close_of_arguments_date"],"post_close_reference_only":[]},"required_fields_before_filing_provisional_relief":["canonical_case_facts.fraudulent_act_date.selected_value or candidate_values","market_value_fields.provisional_value_compensation_base.selected_value","encumbrance_inputs.secured_claims_existing_at_fraudulent_act","plaintiffs[].preserved_claim_principal.litigation_safe_value"],"required_fields_before_final_relief":["runtime_inputs.close_of_arguments_date.value","market_value_fields.property_value_at_close_of_arguments.final_close_selected","common_collateral_value.selected_for_relief","beneficiary_gain.selected_for_relief","plaintiffs[].recovery_cap.selected_for_relief"],"blocking_rules":["filing_provisional 단계에서는 close_of_arguments_date 누락이 blocking이 아니다.","pre_close_finalization 단계에서는 close_of_arguments_date 누락이 blocking이다.","가액배상형인데 provisional_value_compensation_base가 없으면 filing 단계에서도 blocking이다.","근거 없는 단일 market_value_at_close 문자열만 존재하고 candidate table이 비어 있으면 warning이 아니라 blocking이다."],"cross_checks":["각 valuation candidate는 valuation_date, basis_type, evidence_refs를 반드시 가진다.","distance_to_close_days는 close_of_arguments_date가 입력되면 자동 재계산한다.","가압류는 원칙적으로 공제하지 않는다.","공동원고이면 원고별 cap을 분리한다.","원상회복 가능 사안에서 가액배상 단독 주위청구로 출력하지 않는다."],"validation_warnings":[],"finalization_status":{"numeric_finalization_allowed":false,"relief_summary_rendering_allowed":false,"manual_review_required":true}},"output_blocks":{"relief_summary":null,"cause_summary":null,"internal_reasoning_notes":{"why_value_compensation_not_restoration":null,"direct_evidence_fact_ids":[],"missing_inputs":[],"next_required_actions":["필요시 시가감정신청","변론종결 전 권리상태 재확인","청구취지 변경 여부 재검토"]}}}
|